Thoughts, reflections, news, and musings from a veteran Silicon Valley journalist and commentator.

October 10, 2004

Creating Public Domain Textbooks

You ever get the feeling an elephant is sitting in the room and you are one of the few people who can see it?

That's the experience I was having last year when community leaders and members of the faculty and staff at Silicon Valley's two community colleges, Foothill College (in Los Altos Hills) and De Anza College (in Cupertino), asked me to run for a seat on their five-member Governing Board of Trustees.

I accepted the invitation, ran, and won. But many people have asked me why I would do such a crazy thing, particularly considering the long meetings, low pay, and general sense of disapprobation that often attaches itself to elected officials.

The answer is that I ran for a reason, not for an office. I saw an elephant in the foyer of the higher education establishment. I had waited patiently for others to recognize it and when that did not happen with the requisite speed I figured I had a chance to do something about it.

I am a journalist and writer, not an educator. But I simply could not believe that higher education insiders were not moving more rapidly to use the Internet to fight back against the unconscionably high prices millions of eager students around the world must pay for current, high-quality textbooks.

I wrote my first column about a partial solution to this problem in 2001, shortly after it became practical. In a nutshell, the idea is to organize and use public domain materials to create durable, permanent and constantly evolving alternatives to costly textbooks.

Public domain materials are those whose copyrights have either expired, not been renewed, or which were not copyrighted in the first place because their authors wanted to make them freely available. They include books, songs, maps, drawings, plays and virtually any other product of the human imagination. All math textbooks published before 1923, for example, are now in the public domain as are many published after that date. (I use math as an example just because it is one of the fields where old documents can still be current, correct and valuable. In 1923 two plus two equaled four. Last time I checked, it still does, which means many old math books are still relevant today, although the way the material is presented often needs to be reconfigured and updated to make it competitive with current commercial products).

The advent of the Internet made it easier to locate and archive public domain materials, which several groups are now doing. Meanwhile, schools such as MIT and others started encouraging their faculty members to put the materials they use in their classes online for others to use freely, either as public domain materials or with some rights reserved under terms outlined by the free intellectual property licenses offered online by the non-profit organization Creative Commons.

Taken together, these developments have created a mountain of free intellectual property at least some of which can be fashioned into substitutes for textbooks, not only for college students, who are often financially hard-pressed, but also for students at any other level. Surely, I thought, the higher education establishment would quickly seize on this dramatic new opportunity.

But I was wrong.

In fact, I'm not aware of any colleges or schools that have a formal policy or program to provide meaningful support or assistance to faculty members who want to develop and use public domain materials as substitutes for textbooks, despite the years that have passed since doing so became possible. Sure, there is lots of stuff in the public domain, with more appearing each day. But who is organizing the material, mapping or adapting it to fit specific courses, maintaining it, judging it for quality, or supervising a collabrative process to continually improve it?

That's one of the main reasons I agreed to stand for election to the Foothill-De Anza Community College District Governing Board. I saw a chance to champion a new type of investment in public education. In the past, supporters of higher education have worked hard to build university endowments, modernize campus environments, hire more qualified faculty and increase their pay. But we now have a chance to do something more, namely to create free or virtually free learning materials. Organizing this material and making it available over the Internet would directly assist students at our colleges and around the world. The thought that kept running thru my head (and which still does): "Imagine how the world might change and what could happen next if there is a free state-of-the-art physics text, or math text, or chemistry text..."

I've been on the Board for a little less than a year now, and I am pleased to report that we are nearing the adoption of a new Policy on Public Domain Materials. We expect the final hearing on this new policy and its enactment before the end of this year.

In short, the policy asks our administration to find ways and resources to encourage faculty members to organize and use public domain materials in place of textbooks. We've left the specifics about exactly how to do this up to the capable administrators at both colleges, with progress reports coming to our Board at least once a year. The package of incentives and related programs to accomplish this objective has not yet been finalized but it might include release time for faculty so they can prepare these materials, awards and recognition for the best sets of public domain learning materials, and tutorials that help faculty members identify useful public domain resources in their fields.

The overall goal is to come up with sets of public domain materials that can continue to evolve and that draw in collaborators who teach in the same areas of study. My fondest hope is that one day millions of students around the world will have free access to these materials and that fewer motivated learners will be held back because they can't afford to pay for the instructional materials and books they need. Likewise, I want to see the professors and academics who organize these materials get the credit and recognition that will surely come their way once they become known as the stewards of the best and most popular sets of public domain learning materials in their field.

None of this will be easy - nor will it happen fast. But public colleges and universities certainly should provide assistance to faculty members who want to organize public domain learning materials into free or low-cost substitutes for the expensive textbooks used in their classes. After all, what we are really talking about here is using public funds to create a new type of public resource.

The Foothill-De Anza Community College District is about to become the first institution of higher education in the country to formally commit itself to this goal. With any luck, others will soon follow.

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.plotkin.com/cgi-bin/mt2/mt-tb.cgi/5

Comments

WikiBooks (http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Main_Page) is an interesting project that is working on free, open-source textbooks.

Posted by: Philip Dhingra at October 11, 2004 03:13 PM

The mathforum.org has some textbooks like Harry Watson's excellent Differential Equations text.

http://mathforum.org/library/
http://mathforum.org/differential/watson/

Posted by: Anonymous at October 13, 2004 11:21 PM

Wow.

It took me a long time to find a website to someone with the same basic philosophy as me, but then I guess I finally entered the right search parameters and found your link.

I teach a Foundations of Ed class and constantly hear from my students that the prices of books actually make the difference between being able to attend school and having to drop out. I always try to use handouts and photocopied manuals for my class to save students money, but a recent trip to the campus bookstore really blew my mind. $80 for a little piece of shit (mostly fluff) book!!! My students are studying to become the teachers of tomorrow and I want to help them in any way I can to think freely and likewise, attend school "freely".

Can you tell me how to find textbooks that are in the public domain that deal with subjects such as English, Math, History, Reading, Science, and all levels of Teaching (Curriculum, Methods, etc.)?

I think the position you are taking is more than just honorable, it is long overdue. It is unfortunate that many professors, and most schools, make it clear that they are more concerned with making a buck than they are with making a difference.

Thanks,
Andy McNulty, M.S.Ed

P. S. Great thing that you are doing. Keep the faith!

Posted by: Andy McNulty, M.S.Ed at March 21, 2005 07:59 PM

Here's something that might interest you.

Syllabus (http://syllabus.com/ ) has asked me to present my paper (see: http://www.cetis.ac.uk/content2/20050407015813 ) on creative commons textbooks at their conference this summer.

So, in order to give folks here at Berkeley an opportunity to hear the idea, and to weigh in with their perspectives, I'll be presenting the paper this Friday (4/22/2005) in room 4 Dwinelle from noon to 1:30pm.

Best,
Fred

Posted by: Fred M Beshears at April 21, 2005 08:02 PM

So, Have any books been adopted at this point?

A search here: http://www.fhda.edu/
for public domain textbook returns:
Nothing Found

Posted by: Mark Burnet at March 19, 2006 10:01 AM

I believe that public domain textbooks are way over due, and could help the U.S. compete in a hypercompetitive global economy. I also believe that they will not show up in time.

Think for one moment; how much money is spent, annually, to purchase sheet music for the High school bands in the U.S.? Congress has gone insane with modifying copyright law in ways that make no sense in our digital world, yet we need to buy the music for “Star Spangled Banner” over, and over and over again. The mantra is that authors need to be paid for their work, but the reality is that the authors get only the tiniest fraction of the price of these texts, with the rest going to the publishing houses. The high cost of texts puts us at a severe disadvantage with countries like China, where our intellectual property rights are not respected, and our textbooks are reproduced without royalties for a fraction of a percent of the cover price here. So, the price of our textbooks is a tax on the American student that the Chinese don't have to bear.

I had thought that the hold up was simply the lack of people skilled in the technology, but I eventually realized that the educational industry will not accept public domain materials unless they are forced on them. These people are not part of the problem, they ARE the problem!

I would propose that the Department of Education hire some writers to produce some standard text books, oh, and maybe even a few musical arrangements, pay them well for their efforts, and then release them to the public domain. Instead of a single shot of cash, a school district would enjoy a reduced cost of operations each and every year.

Makes too much sense... the publishers will riot when the government messes with their rice bowl. But not to worry... another country will surely adopt this model. Stay tuned!

Posted by: Fred Philibert at March 2, 2007 07:52 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?